Political News | Annuit Coeptis logo

Page added: 13:01 UTC, Saturday, 6th February 2010
Subscribe to our Feedrss feed
Author: James Shott              Category: AC Analysis, All Posts, Columns, Featured, Opinion

Creating rights from hurt feelings

A man went into a Starbucks in Boca Raton, Florida. As it happened, he suffered from Tourette Syndrome, which according to the Tourette Syndrome Association is a neurological disorder which becomes evident in early childhood or before the age of 18 years and is defined by multiple involuntary motor and vocal actions which may include violent acts, as well as obscene words or socially inappropriate words and phrases.

While in the coffee shop the man had a Tourette’s attack and began uncontrollably beating on a wall and cursing loudly. When customers complained, Starbucks employees called the police and had him removed from the premises.

If you’re thinking that the man probably sued Starbucks, go to the head of the class. He claims that workers at the coffee shop violated his civil rights when he began cursing loudly and punching the wall, disturbing and perhaps terrifying other patrons in the coffee shop.

The Florida Commission on Human Relations, which investigates claims of discrimination, claimed there was evidence that Starbucks did not take steps to accommodate the man’s disability, but did not say, of course, what an accommodation for a man screaming obscenities and pounding on a wall uncontrollably would be.

Situations like this are troubling on several levels. We don’t want to mistreat people who have problems they can’t control. But, on the other hand, businesses like Starbucks are not therapy centers. They can’t effectively do what they do, and at the same time incorporate accommodations for every conceivable disability that might come through their doors. More to the point, how do you accommodate people who may, without notice, simply break into fits of violent behavior, or begin shouting profanity?

Furthermore, don’t businesses have an obligation to their non-Tourette Syndrome customers – who comprise the vast majority of their customers, including children – to provide an environment without such aberrant behavior?

Life is not fair; people are not equal. Some of us are not equipped to play a particular sport, despite how badly we may want to. Some of us are incapable of becoming an engineer, or a computer programmer or a designer, even though that is the goal to which we aspire. And some of us have specific problems, such as a disease or disorder, which limit what we can do.

Someone with a disorder like Tourette Syndrome does not have a right to go to Starbucks and disturb other patrons by pounding on the wall and cursing loudly, and Starbucks does not have an obligation to accommodate people with Tourette Syndrome.

If you have a medical condition that produces unpredictable disruptive behavior, you simply have to avoid going to public places where your behavior will be offensive or dangerous to innocent bystanders, and you are not entitled to sue for compensation for your disability. That’s unfortunate for people with Tourette Syndrome, but that’s the way it is.

These situations prompt sympathy both for the Tourette’s sufferer and for Starbucks, but they are not legitimate subjects for law suits. To the contrary, such law suits are strong evidence in support of tort reform.

Share and Enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • email
  • Facebook
  • Print
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Fleck
  • Propeller
  • Mixx
  • connotea
  • Furl
  • IndianPad
  • Faves
  • blogmarks
  • Folkd
  • LinkaGoGo
  • MisterWong

Tags: , , , ,

  1. You say the man sued, but you don’t say if the case went to court or how it was disposed. Is there any more information you can provide?

  2. James Shott says:

    The story ran Feb. 2 about the incident which occurred “last year.”

    Not much detail in the story.

  3. NEPAConservative says:

    If this guy wasn’t wearing a tag that said I have Tourette how were the employees to know that the guy wasn’t under the influence and maybe even packing heat. PLUS would you give a guy a hot coffee that is flipping out putting other customers at risk?!?!

    I am looking for the text of this suit but this is about as frivolous as it gets. The lawyer that agreed to take this case is the exact reason why all of our insurance premiums are so damn high. Tort reform YES!

    Reasonable accommodation? I think calling the police was about as accommodating as they needed to get. The police may have stopped him from hurting himself and or others.




:p 8) :lol: =( :8 ;) :(( :o: :[ :) :D :-| :-[) :bloody: :cool: :choler: :love: :oups: :aie: :beurk:

Related Stories

Latest Headlines

Also In The News

Sheridan Folger: Today the Jig Man Danced on the Phone thumbnail
Demonizing for political gain thumbnail
Pelosi: Lawmakers aren’t in Washington for job security… thumbnail

Bad Behavior has blocked 917 access attempts in the last 7 days.